Bruno's Championships
- GPW Tag Team Championship - with Édouard Carpentier
- NWA International Tag Team Championship (Toronto version) - with Whipper Billy Watson
- NWA United States Heavyweight Championship (Toronto version)
- WWA World Tag Team Championship - with Dick the Bruiser
- WWF International Tag Team Championship (2 times) - with Dominic DeNucci and Tony Marino
- WWWF United States Tag Team Championship (1 time) - with Spiros Arion
- WWWF World Heavyweight Championship (2 times)
- PWI Match of the Year (1972) Battle royal on January 14, Los Angeles, CA
- PWI Match of the Year (1975) vs. Spiros Arion on March 17, New York, NY
- PWI Match of the Year (1976) vs. Stan Hansen on April 26, New York, NY
- PWI Match of the Year (1977) vs. Billy Graham on April 30, Baltimore, MD
- PWI Match of the Year (1980) vs. Larry Zbyszko at Showdown at Shea in a steel cage match
- PWI Most Inspirational Wrestler of the Year (1976)
- PWI Stanley Weston Award (1981)
- PWI Wrestler of the Year (1974)
Wrestling Observer Newsletter Awards
- Feud of the Year (1980) vs. Larry Zbyszko
- Wrestling Observer Newsletter Hall of Fame Class of 1996
Professional Wrestling Hall of Fame and Museum
- Hall of Fame Class of 2002
World Wide Wrestling Alliance
- Hall of Fame Class of 2008
Other Titles
- Madison Square Garden walk of fame
- Received the Key to the City in Franklin, Pennsylvania on March 24, 2007
- Received The Dapper Dan Award Lifetime Achievement Award on March 25, 2010 at the Petersen Events Center.